Borough engineer updates committee on troubled Walnut Street project

The 600 block of Walnut Street has been closed at various times this week for remedial work.

Contractors are currently scrambling to finish remedial work on several Walnut Street sidewalks. The sidewalks are part of an overall road project on the 500 and 600 blocks that includes road paving, curbs, and ramps. As Columbia Spy reported HERE, property owners on the two blocks complained to borough council recently about various problems with the project.

C.S. Davidson’s Derek Rinaldo (second from left) reports on the Walnut Street road project.

In response, engineering firm C.S. Davidson provided information and updates on the project at the borough’s November Public Works and Property Committee meeting. The firm’s representative, Derek Rinaldo, who serves as the borough’s Engineer of Record, told the committee, “We’re aware of several issues on that street right now.” He named cracking concrete, blocked drains, and overspray as a few of those issues. Rinaldo said he developed a punch list of over 20 items after walking the site several times with the borough’s Ron Miller and Jake Graham. [Miller is Public Works Director, and Graham is Highway Department Manager.]

Regarding concrete cracking, Rinaldo said, “We’re not concerned with the integrity of the concrete.” He pointed out that the concrete used for the job is rated at 4,000 psi and must meet borough standards based on PennDOT 408 specifications that govern various aspects of construction.

Two sinkholes opened up on the 600 block.

During sidewalk installation, another problem became apparent: a sinkhole that opened near 647 Walnut. Rinaldo said a urethane injection method is typically used to fill in any voids and spaces associated with a sinkhole. In the process, a spray foam is injected underneath the road and curb, which expands to fill the affected area. A second sinkhole opened this past Sunday, near 651 Walnut.

Contractors are also filling in the so-called “beauty strips” with concrete.
Rinaldo noted that water was flowing over the curb and onto the sidewalk during high-intensity rains. He explained that the problem stems from the fact that the 600 block of Walnut takes drainage from the three blocks further up as well as from several side streets. To help resolve the problem, drains will be added in the 700 and 800 blocks during next year’s planned road project. Contractors are also filling in the so-called “beauty strips” with concrete to control water. 
Contractors are working to correct problems on the 600 block of Walnut Street

Another possible factor contributing to drainage problems, according to Rinaldo, is the street’s high crown. Unfortunately, lowering the crown would require tearing up and totally reconstructing the street, potentially adding several hundred thousand dollars to the cost. Rinaldo said testing and core samples of the street did not show a need for reconstruction, because the base is strong. Profile milling was done instead; that is, taking a very small amount of material off the top and replacing it with petromat, a fiber-containing paving material that provides an extra layer of strength over trench cuts and divots.

Problems on the 500 block are also being addressed.
Rinaldo explained that other jobs he’s been involved with in the borough did not have these kinds of problems and that this is the third or fourth project he’s done with Pennsy Supply. Pennsy installed the sidewalks on the 600 block, while a subcontractor, Sauder Brothers Concrete, did the 500 block. The total project cost for the two blocks was a little over $432,000. Rinaldo said no contractors have been paid so far. 
[UPDATE 11/30/18: According to a source, contractors have been paid, except for the final 5%.]

0 thoughts on “Borough engineer updates committee on troubled Walnut Street project”

  1. R citizen How do you know it was done to specs and the borough being union has a lot to do with the pay scale . If the engineer oked this the firm should be fired , but contractor s that aren't watched do this kind of sloppy work and it looks like Columbia's inspectors were on the take or just not there, thru this job anyone could see the out come, so it seams they weren't there. Fill out a wright to know for the specs and see and tell us what you find. Are the storm drains large enough to support more water from upper blocks, if not the job should have been stopped until we put new drains in , now if they aren't (yup) dig it up again. WHERE WAS THE COLUMBIA INSPECTER AND HIS DAILY NOTES ON THE JOB??? BOROUGH MANAGER SHOULD ANSWER THESE QUESTIONS TO THE PUBLIC !! INEXPERENCED this is not going to be the last of these things , more to come, thank you council ,your back door shi- bites the tax payers again.

    Like

  2. this has been one of the rainiest wettest years on record, only topped once. that is a huge part of the problem pertaining to Walnut St. I'm NOT saying that the contractor did a questionable job. I'm sorry that this happened, but my point is, the Borough and it's Engineer are handling the issues, knowing there are problems and trying to correct them. You see, there are no magic balls that tell you when you are working on one item, that another sinkhole is opening up. This is an extreme common occurance the past few years, and Pennsylvania is near the top of the list. Give them the chance to have everything done correctly. The Borough didn't do the work, it was bid out. Let them do what needs done.

    Like

  3. They saved several hundred thousand to leave the crown on knowing problems will happen ,BUT THEY SPEND MILLIONS ON THE MONEY PIT hum council ? mayor ? we are paying you people, and the borough manager ?????

    Like

  4. A normal street you can pull a string across curb to curb and it touches in the middle (6inch slope) What is going on here.

    Like

  5. It's time something is done with the council and Mayor all they do is spend money and the Manager thinks we are a big city. She needs to get a better hold on things in this Small Boro. We also have too many employees for the size of our town. Clean out and save us TAX money.

    Like

Leave a reply to Anonymous Cancel reply