Who really fired Chris Vera (and why isn’t he allowed on borough property)?

Frank Doutrich addresses council at the March 27 meeting.

At the March 27, 2025 Columbia Borough Council meeting, the dismissal of former market manager Chris Vera was a key topic of discussion. Vera was fired for “performance concerns,” according to a March 5 letter of termination. 

Columbia Borough Manager Steven Kaufhold stated the firing “wasn’t an easy decision” and noted that council was criticized on social media about the termination. Kaufhold explained that as borough manager, difficult decisions sometimes need to be made, and emphasized: “The sole decision to terminate Chris was mine.”

Kaufhold: “The sole decision to terminate Chris was mine.” [Columbia Spy file photo]

Resident Frank Doutrich addressed council with concerns: “I don’t know what he’s done, but council didn’t make it great or easy by saying he’s not allowed on the borough property. I don’t know where you people are coming from when you bring that out.” (Doutrich was referring to a March 12 letter of no trespass informing Vera that he is not allowed on borough property. Vera provided that letter to Columbia Spy, which is published HERE.)

Doutrich, who said he has attended council meetings for over 50 years, questioned how council could implement such a policy, asking: “What if he’s got to come in here and pay a bill? What if he gets a ticket, and he’s got to go pay the ticket? He’s not allowed on borough property?” 

Councilwoman Barb Fisher said she didn’t know of the letter until that night: “This is news to me. So to say that council did that, I had no idea that was done until tonight and I heard it from you guys.” Doutrich replied: “You didn’t know that he had a letter, but I thought council makes those decisions.” He added: “I didn’t think the borough manager made that without council.” Council President Heather Zink explained: “That’s a legal decision, and that is done by our solicitor.” 

To cut through the confusion, Doutrich asked directly who actually fired Vera. Kaufhold responded: “I did.”

Zink: “That’s a legal decision, and that is done by our solicitor.” [Columbia Spy file photo]

Borough Solicitor Evan Gabel clarified, apparently addressing Zink: “He [Kaufhold] recommended to you to fire Chris. It needed to happen immediately, but council immediately pursuant to your borough code is the one who’s the decision maker on this.” Zink acknowledged this with “Yes,” adding that council was now ratifying the termination. 

Doutrich emphasized: “I know council hires and fires. That’s the way I was always taught.” He also noted that Zink had said at a previous meeting that termination does not require a council vote. Zink acknowledged her error: “That was my misunderstanding. I’m sorry. And that’s why I put it on [the agenda] for tonight.”

Doutrich: “To say that you’re not allowed on borough property, I’m sorry I can’t buy that. That’s just not right.” [Columbia Spy file photo]

Regarding the property ban, Doutrich said: “To say that you’re not allowed on borough property, I’m sorry I can’t buy that. That’s just not right.” 

Mayor Leo Lutz characterized the property ban as “standard procedure” that had occurred “quite a few times in the past.” When Doutrich asked for examples of fired employees who had been banned, Lutz replied: “Probably everybody that left, including officers. It’s a standard management decision.”

Lutz: “It’s a standard management decision.” [Columbia Spy file photo]

When Doutrich asked if Vera would be arrested for coming to pay a bill, Gabel confirmed: “That is correct.” Gabel explained: “Part of that letter is that he is not a resident of the borough, so there’s far less reason for him to ever come onto borough property, if he’s not an employee of the borough, which he no longer is. The intent of that letter was that he not come back on borough property.”

Following discussion, council voted unanimously to ratify the termination of Vera as market manager.

Council then voted to hire Bonnie Link, who had been serving as interim manager since Vera’s departure. She will receive a starting annual salary of $56,822, and Kaufhold recommended she receive back pay to March 5th. Link will need to give up her market stand to avoid conflicts of interest.

When Doutrich questioned why the position wasn’t advertised, Kaufhold explained it was a management position. Gabel clarified: “It does not have to be advertised. No non-union position ever has to be advertised.”

A letter from Chris Vera to friends and supporters of the Columbia Market House is posted HERE.

Deeds Recorded – Columbia Borough – March 31, 2025

Capriotti Jane M, Hinkle Joseph L. Jr. conveyed 160 S. Eighth St. to Scritchfield Aaron G, Buckwalter Angelina for $276,000.

Cimarron Investments LLC, Whitestone Partners LLC, Leonard R. James, Leonard Diane L, Goodman Heather M, Montgomery Sarah N, Kostoff Amy S, Route 322 Keystone Courts Mobile Home Park LLC, Wayne Thomas LLC, Thomas Wayne LLC conveyed property on a public road to Cimarron Investments LLC for $1.

Cimarron Investments LLC conveyed 20 N. Second St. to CFH Holdings LLC for $1.

Cimarron Investments LLC conveyed 28 N. Second St. to CFH oldings LLC for $1.

Whitestone Partners LLC conveyed 30 N. Second St. to CFH Holdings LLC for $1.

Wayne Thomas Llc, Thomas Wayne LLC conveyed 156 Walnut St. to CFH Holdings LLC for $1.

Proverb Realty LLC conveyed 152 Walnut St. to CFH Holdings LLC for $1.

Proverb Realty LLC conveyed 150 Walnut St. to CFH Holdings LLC for $1.

Cimarron Investments LLC conveyed 161 Locust St. to CFH Holdings LLC for $1.

About Town – March 30, 2025

 This week’s photos of Columbia 

Click on photos to see larger, sharper images. 

Columbia 10th grader Cayden is collecting for his college fund by playing sax at Janson Park a few times a week.

Here, Cayden is playing sax, accompanied by church bells.

Sidewalk art on Walnut Street 

Free

Columbia Curiosities, on the 300 block of Walnut, always has cool stuff . . .

******************

Old-time street lamp at 3rd & Cherry

River Trail Parking 

Downspout at the District Administration Center 

Why does it say 1953?

And where’s the downspout on the other side?

Seen at Columbia River Park 

The Tin Man is on the 300 block of Locust. 

Hyacinth 

Crazy numbers

Cacti in Avenue G

Ace of Fades held a benefit on Saturday for fallen officer Andrew Duarte. 

Sticker shock!

Braces, such as this one, have been added to utility poles around town.

Missing glass

Empty market 

South Central Transit Authority workers took down the bus stop shelter on Locust Street.

*****************

Wood Bros.

Can people ski in Columbia?

Nails & Lashes

Keep your hands out of the husking rolls!

Signs of spring

AAA

Locust Street scene

Ornate stonework on a mausoleum at Mount Bethel 

Mechanical cage

Gears, belts, chains, and such

Free

Stacked

Cool car

Another sign of Easter

The remains of a rusty fish?

Everybody has an addiction. 

This starling seems to be pondering those round things. 

Sidewalk pattern

Turkey Hill crates: good for sitting, storing books, and carrying all manner of things

A CBS21 reporter was in town to cover claims of bullying at the high school. 

Heavy stones make up a retaining wall in Avenue G.

The U.S. flag appears to be burning, due to construction dust in the background. 

Railroad workers were once again at the entrance to the borough sheds. 

*****************

This bell on Chestnut Street likely has some historical significance related to Columbia. 

More daffodils 

Is Columbia a bicycle-friendly borough?

This is one of several steel plates around town. 

###

Yard Waste pickup begins Monday, March 31, 2025

Yard Waste pickup begins in Columbia Borough on Monday, March 31, 2025.

As a mandated municipality with more than 10,000 residents, Columbia Borough is required by PA Act 101 to collect leaves and yard waste material.  Yard waste collection significantly reduces the amount of material taken to the landfill each year and increases the storage capacity and lifecycle of our local landfill.

Yard Waste and Leaf Collection is announced every year and begins as soon as weather permits.  Once started, yard waste will take place Mondays and continues through Fall. 

Ace of Fades Barbershop will host fundraiser on Saturday to honor fallen West York Borough Police Officer Andrew Duarte | fox43.com

https://www.fox43.com/article/news/local/morning-show/ace-of-fades-barbershop-fundraiser-for-fallen-west-york-borough-police-officer-andrew-duarte/521-17e5b361-f8ee-4f41-8f9a-402f417f96d5

Manheim Borough man pays $500 fine for crash that killed Columbia man | Local News | lancasteronline.com

JACK PANYARD | LNP Staff Writer

A Manheim Borough who man caused a fatal motorcycle crash in East Donegal Township in July was charged, pleaded guilty and paid a $500 fine to settle his case.

Gabriel Sullivan, 20, was charged with one count of careless driving resulting in unintentional death last week for the July 7 crash that killed Kyle Anthony Costrello, 33, of Columbia, at Anderson Ferry and Ore Mine roads.

Susquehanna Regional Police said Sullivan’s Oldsmobile collided with Costrello’s motorcycle as Sullivan was turning onto Ore Mine Road from Anderson Ferry. Costrello was ejected from his motorcycle and died of his injuries. Sullivan’s Oldsmobile also hit another car but neither driver was injured.

Police charged Sullivan March 19, and he pleaded guilty and was fined Wednesday.

According to Pennsylvania law, someone can be charged with careless driving if they operate a “vehicle in careless disregard for the safety of persons or property.” If they kill someone, they can be charged with a summary offense of unintentional death, which results in a $500 fine.

For someone to be charged with homicide by vehicle, a third-degree felony, they would have to be driving with gross negligence, which is decided by investigators. If convicted, they could spend up to seven years in prison if sober, or 10 if they were under the influence of drugs or alcohol.

https://lancasteronline.com/news/local/manheim-borough-man-pays-500-fine-for-fatal-july-crash/article_c779fce1-54ac-45df-9e07-e56cfa272cb9.html

Restaurant Inspections – Columbia Borough – March 28, 2025


Living River Herbals, 15 S. Third St., Columbia, Opening, March 22. Pass. No violations.

Columbia High School, 901 Ironville Pike, Columbia, March 18. Pass. Hard-boiled eggs, a refrigerated, ready-to-eat, time/temperature-control-for-safety food in the walk-in cooler, was date-marked by the facility but was beyond the seven-day use-by date and requires discarding. Old food residue observed on the inner rim of the slicer and on a couple of scoops.

Level Up Pizza, 237 Locust St., Columbia, March 18. Pass. Observed raw beef stored on top of cooked gyro meat in the reach-in cooler. Refrigerated, ready-to-eat, time/temperature-control-for-safety food (taco meat, camarones and chicken) prepared in the food facility and held for more than 24 hours, located in the reach-in cooler, is not being date marked. Meatballs, a refrigerated, ready-to-eat, time/temperature-control-for-safety food in the reach-in cooler, was date-marked by the facility but was beyond the seven-day use- or sell-by date and requires discarding. Observed two mouse traps inside the hand-wash sink in the food preparation area. Observed mouse feces in the back corner of the food preparation area. Food facility using rodent bait placed in bait stations, which are not covered and tamper resistant.

Salem United Church of Christ, 324 Walnut St., Columbia, March 18. Pass. No violations.